{"id":2143908,"date":"2022-04-10T19:00:00","date_gmt":"2022-04-10T17:00:00","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/?p=2143908"},"modified":"2022-04-11T02:46:41","modified_gmt":"2022-04-11T00:46:41","slug":"not-so-fast-will-smith-chris-rock-and-the-academy-there-are-more-people-who-deserve-apologies-column","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/2022\/04\/not-so-fast-will-smith-chris-rock-and-the-academy-there-are-more-people-who-deserve-apologies-column\/","title":{"rendered":"Not So Fast Will Smith, Chris Rock and the Academy: There Are More People Who Deserve Apologies (Column)"},"content":{"rendered":"<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><b>Variety awards editor urges the Academy, Will Smith and Chris Rock to directly apologize to Jada Pinkett Smith, Oscar hosts and many more.<\/b><br \/>\nWill Smith, Chris Rock and the Academy may feel they can turn the page on this dramatic chapter following the announcement that Smith would be banned from the ceremony for 10 years. But there\u2019s too much reliance on written statements and not enough acknowledgment that multiple apologies are missing from all parties. For Smith, who won best actor for his performance as Serena and Venus Williams\u2019 father in \u201cKing Richard,\u201d an Instagram post saying he \u201caccepts and respect the Academy\u2019s decision\u201d is not the type of penance the general public, the industry, your colleagues and co-stars are expecting. For Rock, he shouldn\u2019t be gearing up to cash in for some standup comedy special about what happened, and his silence about his role in this ordeal has been deafening. For the Academy, an acknowledgement to Rock for not making the situation worse, or for not kicking Smith out of the room is only the tip of the iceberg for the radical changes that are needed within your organization to ensure the Oscars can survive until the end of Smith\u2019s \u201c10-year sentence.\u201d However, Smith isn\u2019t the only villain in this story. There isn\u2019t even a \u201cgood guy\u201d in this tale, only many people who made bad decisions. Smith has received his punishment, but that doesn\u2019t absolve the Academy nor Rock\u2019s responsibility and their need to make amends to more than one party. The road to redemption must include an acknowledgment of all the parties hurt and affected, making amends and putting certain practices in place to ensure lessons are learned and applied to prevent future mistakes. That list must include actress Jada Pinkett Smith, producer Joseph Patel, the Oscar hosts Regina Hall, Amy Schumer and Wanda Sykes, the producers and staff of the telecast, and every viewer in attendance, and at home who were force-fed the revisionist history and messaging that came afterward. No more hiding behind surgically curated statements and tweets. It\u2019s time to make direct amends with all hurt parties by Smith, Rock and the Academy. No one is standing tall after this year\u2019s telecast. I\u2019m not saying Smith\u2019s punishment is not warranted, as walking up to a stage and slapping someone during a live telecast was beyond reprehensible. It\u2019s not just the act of assault, but the stain on the legacy of the very few Black people who have won lead actor or actress statuettes in 94 years. Smith is only the fifth, and he\u2019s now synonymous with what is arguably the craziest moment in the ceremony\u2019s history. While some will look at the Academy\u2019s ruling as excessive, and others say it doesn\u2019t go far enough, the truth is there was little to no recourse for the Board of Governors, given Smith\u2019s resignation from the Academy on April 1. As he is no longer a member, Smith was no longer subject to other censures or financial sanctions the Academy could levy. Rest assured, if he had still been an active member during Friday\u2019s board meeting, expulsion from the Academy would have been a likely outcome, but perhaps with a shorter ban from future ceremonies. The calls for the Academy to \u201ctake back\u201d the statuette, or for Smith to return it himself, are downright embarrassing. The ballots were in, and the votes were tabulated. There isn\u2019t an \u201cundo\u201d feature for the Academy Awards, and if there was, it\u2019s not certain a multiverse revisionist cross-correction of the 2021 best actor race would be at the top of the list. If Smith were to \u201creturn\u201d it, then what? Do you re-engrave it with the names of Benedict Cumberbatch (\u201cThe Power of the Dog\u201d) or Andrew Garfield (\u201cTick, Tick\u2026 Boom!\u201d)? Indeed either of them becoming \u201cAcademy Award winner\u201d with an asterisk (*) next to their name for the rest of time would not be fair to two people who had nothing to do with these events. What about the celebrities that have \u201crefused\u201d their Oscar but are still considered \u201cwinners?\u201d Marlon Brando refused his statuette for \u201cThe Godfather\u201d (1972), sending Sacheen Littlefeather in his place the same night that John Wayne reportedly had to be restrained by security guards because he was trying to charge the stage. Where are the calls to \u201ctake back\u201d his Oscar for \u201cTrue Grit\u201d (1969)? Oh, is it because it didn\u2019t happen during the night of his win, so that it makes it \u201capples and oranges,\u201d or is perception and tarnished images enough punishment for Smith to endure for the rest of his days? Harvey Weinstein doesn\u2019t have access to his Oscar from his jail cell (for best picture for \u201cShakespeare in Love\u201d), and Roman Polanski (director winner for \u201cThe Pianist\u201d) is a fugitive from the law after raping a child, but, sure, let\u2019s have the fifth Black actor in history return his award because he slapped someone. That isn\u2019t very sensible. When it comes to the consequences that Smith could have received, we can have a lively debate on what was appropriate, but it comes down to what was available for the Board of Governors to impose. Multiple sources within the Academy and its Board have shared that members of Academy leadership were upset by Smith\u2019s resignation ahead of their originally planned April 18 meeting. But, honestly, what option did he have after what looks to be a blatantly wrong explanation of what happened following \u201cthe slap?\u201d After the Academy released a statement saying it asked Smith to leave but he refused, something that multiple sources have refuted, he was no longer just the guy who slapped Chris Rock on the air. He is now an angry Black man who performed an egregious assault on someone and, in addition, is also a celebrity who resists removal from a venue because he feels entitled to be there. That version of events as detailed by the Academy, it could be argued, caused far more damage to Smith\u2019s career and public image than the slap itself. It\u2019s another example of art imitating life, but not in the way Smith referenced during his Oscar speech. It reminds me of Smith and actress Janet Hubert\u2019s conversation on \u201cThe Fresh Prince of Bel-Air Reunion\u201d that aired on HBO Max in 2020. In their tearful exchange and recollections of the events that led to her leaving the 1990s sitcom, Hubert says to Smith: \u201cWords can kill. I lost everything, reputation, everything. I understand you were able to move forward, but you know those words, calling a Black woman difficult, in Hollywood, is the kiss of death.\u201d The Academy must reflect on its actions when they say Smith \u201crefused.\u201d Then, acknowledge it, make amends, and do better moving forward. Still, there are other issues for AMPAS that don\u2019t begin with Will Smith. His 10-year ban seems to come with an underlying message \u2014 you can be a horrible person, even violent within the confines of your office or home, spew racist remarks, and even be known for sexual misconduct, but as long as that takes place outside the Dolby Theatre on Oscar night, you are welcome. There are dozens of problematic figures within the Hollywood studios and networks in Hollywood who sit among the Academy\u2019s members. However, they can and regularly do attend the Oscars. The Academy\u2019s Standards of Conduct was a decent start in December 2017, but now, it must be expanded upon. There have been multiple calls to have Smith \u201ctarred and feathered,\u201d professionally speaking. So how do you address the problematic members of your past and create a system that will make the consequences for a breach of the \u201cStandards of Conduct\u201d feel consistent? If Smith were a member of the Academy at the time of the Board meeting, what would have been his ultimate fate? Smith likely knew he was facing down the barrel of expulsion from the Academy, something only five people in history have faced: Should Smith be included in the same sentence as those figures? As society sits divided on how we should react to wrongful acts committed by celebrities, it\u2019s essential to highlight the reaction to Smith\u2019s act and what the Academy leadership was being called upon to do. The people who decry the \u201cwoke mindset\u201d and \u201cherd mentality\u201d wanted to see the blood of the Oscar-winning actor smeared for public display. Smith displayed blatant mistakes, but that\u2019s not solely on him. Chris Rock isn\u2019t squeaky clean in this mess either, despite being the \u201cvictim\u201d of the slap. There have been reports that Rock didn\u2019t know that Pinkett suffered from alopecia, and if true, we\u2019ll take him at his word. However, his joke about her bald head (no matter what Bill Maher\u2019s vapid takes on the matter are) has had media analysts and consumers restating the first amendment as a pledge of allegiance to the protection of free speech. They equate Smith\u2019s assault on Rock as a dangerous precedent in the freedom to \u201csay whatever you want.\u201d Comedy is not some untouchable entity unburdened from consequences and criticism, as much as people have been using as defenses for figures like Dave Chappelle, Louis C.K., and others. You can\u2019t say anything you want just because you have the right to do so. Words do have consequences, and they can hurt. You never know what\u2019s going on with someone internally. The classy thing to do would be for him to apologize to Jada directly, since she was visibly upset by the joke. Rock also made a disrespectful joke after the slap when announcing \u201cSummer of Soul\u201d as the documentary winner. \u201cThe Oscar goes to \u201cAhmir \u2018Questlove\u2019 Thompson and a group of four white guys,\u201d Rock said at the time. Not only do all the winners deserve to be named, but even worse, one of the producers, Joseph Patel, is South Asian, one of three that won on the same evening. This wasn\u2019t a joke he made on the fly after being slapped. Rock made the quip during the rehearsal the day before. In the Academy\u2019s statement, the organization expressed \u201cdeep gratitude to Mr. Rock for maintaining his composure under extraordinary circumstances.\u201d It should be noted that Rock\u2019s reaction could have worsened a terrible situation. Unfortunately, however, there\u2019s still been no apology to Pinkett or Patel individually by either the Academy or Rock\u2019s camp. Apologies are needed all around, and there\u2019s no winner in this situation. As far as I\u2019m concerned, they all lost that night. But again, to be clear, this doesn\u2019t absolve Smith\u2019s acts in any manner. The Academy must address the image of inconsistency following the punishments for misconduct. For example, convicted criminals Weinstein and Polanski would be allowed, in theory, to attend a future ceremony if another attendee chose to bring them as their guests. While the Academy can probably safely rely on the fact that the two will be tied up in litigation and its members wouldn\u2019t commit career suicide by bringing them into the Dolby, Trump\u2019s election to the presidency has shown us that no wrong choice, no matter how blatantly obvious, can be left up to chance. Look at someone like Cosby. He was expelled the same day as Polanski, one month after his conviction. Since then, his conviction has been overturned. Should he have his membership reinstated since he\u2019s no longer a convicted criminal? Of course not, but the organization has left itself vulnerable to potentially harmful (and stupid) choices if the wrong people voice a concern. They\u2019ll have to revisit its policies and make them crystal clear. And finally, there\u2019s the role of the general public and social media commenters, who should also do their best to allow the latitude for mistakes seen as problematic only in hindsight. We can hotly debate the actions of others during past ceremonies, such as Adrien Brody kissing Halle Berry against the actress\u2019 will after winning best actor and even the decision not to remove Smith from the room. The Academy has apologized for its shortcomings there and that is something we should respect. Suppose the Academy, Rock and Smith take the proper steps to show their remorse and responsibility. Only then can we all finally move on \u2013 and go back to making sure that eight below-the-line Oscar categories will never be pre-taped at a future ceremony ever again. The history-making winners of this year\u2019s Oscars have been nearly overshadowed due to Smith\u2019s actions, including Ariana DeBose (\u201cWest Side Story\u201d) as the first queer woman of color to win an acting award, Troy Kotsur (\u201cCODA\u201d) being the first male deaf actor to win, not to mention the industry-wide significance of \u201cCODA\u201d becoming the film released by a streaming platform to win best picture. For the respect for those who have had their spotlights lost in the shuffle, let\u2019s allow their achievements to lead further 94th Oscars stories \u2014 at least while our culpable partakers heed the aforementioned advice.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Variety awards editor urges the Academy, Will Smith and Chris Rock to directly apologize to Jada Pinkett Smith, Oscar hosts and many more. Will Smith, Chris Rock and the Academy may feel they can turn the page on this dramatic chapter following the announcement that Smith would be banned from the ceremony for 10 years. [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":2143907,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[113],"tags":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2143908"}],"collection":[{"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=2143908"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2143908\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/2143907"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=2143908"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=2143908"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=2143908"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}