{"id":3216548,"date":"2025-06-05T15:46:00","date_gmt":"2025-06-05T13:46:00","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/?p=3216548"},"modified":"2025-06-06T08:15:18","modified_gmt":"2025-06-06T06:15:18","slug":"understanding-the-big-beautiful-bill-and-the-laws-that-surround-it","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/2025\/06\/understanding-the-big-beautiful-bill-and-the-laws-that-surround-it\/","title":{"rendered":"Understanding the Big Beautiful Bill and the Laws That Surround It"},"content":{"rendered":"<p style=\"text-align: justify;\"><b>Array<\/b><br \/>\nThe Big Beautiful Bill continues to be confusing, and, frankly, I think it\u2019s become confusing because a whole lot of people think it being confusing is to their advantage. So let\u2019s try to drill down into the details and try to sort out the facts.<br \/>Now, Stephen Miller has tweeted an explanation a couple of times, apparently to little avail, but let\u2019s look at it again, and work out the details.<br \/>I\u2019ve seen a few claims making the rounds on the Big Beautiful Bill that require correction.<br \/>The first is that it doesn\u2019t \u201ccodify the DOGE cuts.\u201d A reconciliation bill, which is a budget bill that passes with 50 votes, is limited by senate rules to \u201cmandatory\u201d spending only \u2014 eg\u2026\u2014 Stephen Miller (@StephenM) May 25, 2025<br \/>Here\u2019s the full text, to which I\u2019ll be referring quite a bit.<br \/>I\u2019ve seen a few claims making the rounds on the Big Beautiful Bill that require correction.<br \/>The first is that it doesn\u2019t \u201ccodify the DOGE cuts.\u201d A reconciliation bill, which is a budget bill that passes with 50 votes, is limited by senate rules to \u201cmandatory\u201d spending only \u2014 eg Medicaid and Food Stamps. The senate rules prevent it from cutting \u201cdiscretionary\u201d spending \u2014 eg the Department of Education or federal grants. The DOGE cuts are overwhelmingly discretionary, not mandatory. The bill saves more than 1.6 TRILLION in mandatory spending, including the largest-ever welfare reform. A remarkable achievement.<br \/>I\u2019ve also seen claims the bill increases the deficit. This lie is based on a CBO accounting gimmick. Income tax rates from the 2017 tax cut are set to expire in September. They were always planned to be permanent. CBO says maintaining current rates adds to the deficit, but by definition leaving these income tax rates unchanged cannot add one penny to the deficit. The bill\u2019s spending cuts REDUCE the deficit against the current law baseline, which is the only correct baseline to use.<br \/>Another fantastically false claim is that the bill spends trillions of dollars. This is just completely invented out of whole cloth. This is not a ten year budget bill\u2014it doesn\u2019t \u201cfund\u201d almost any operations of government, which are funded in the annual budget bills (which this is not). In other words, if this bill passed, but the annual budget bill did not, there would be no government funding. Under the math that critics are using, if we passed a one paragraph reconciliation bill that cut simply 50 billion in food stamp spending, they would say the bill \u201cadded\u201d trillions in spending and debt because they are counting ALL the projected federal spending that exists entirely outside the scope of this legislation, which is of course preposterous. The only funding in the bill is for the President\u2019s border and defense priorities, while enacting a net spending cut of over 1.6 TRILLION dollars.<br \/>The bill has two fiscal components: a massive tax cut and a massive spending cut.<br \/>There are some facts of life that he tries to explain but doesn\u2019t go into detail about, because, well, it\u2019s just a tweet.<br \/>So here are the facts of life:<br \/>The Big Beautiful Bill is a reconciliation bill<br \/>Reconciliation bills have the advantage that they can\u2019t be filibustered \u2014 a simple majority does the job<br \/>.but that doesn\u2019t mean filibusters aren\u2019t an issue in the whole process<br \/>One of the biggest restrictions on reconciliation is that the reconciliation bill cannot, by law, affect anything except mandatory spending, and what constitutes mandatory spending is also established by law.<br \/>Reconciliation bills are not spending bills. They establish a budget, or propose a budget, but the actual spending must be established in a bill that starts in the House. A separate bill.<br \/>Reconciliation bills are scored by the Congressional Budget Office, which imposes other restrictions<br \/>Both the limits on a reconciliation bill and on CBO\u2019s scoring are established by law, so if you want to change them, you run into that filibuster monster again.<br \/> So, a lot of the people screaming about the BBB not codifying the DOGE cuts are either ignorant or gaslighting you. The BBB doesn\u2019t codify the DOGE cuts because by law it can\u2019t. Keep that in mind as we go through the details.<br \/>I think the first thing is probably to look at the CBO scoring, because a lot of the more blatant gaslighting on all sides comes from people conveniently not understanding what the CBO is required by law to do. You can expect that phrase to show up a lot, and, by God, it\u2019s going to be in boldface every time, because it seems to be the hardest thing to understand \u2014 or the easiest thing to ignore.<br \/>So, let\u2019s dive in. I\u2019m going to be quoting my research assistant Grok fairly heavily, because this is buried in probably a hundred different laws, rules, and accounting terms of art that don\u2019t mean quite what you think they mean.<br \/>The Congressional Budget Office \u2014 which is going to be \u201cthe CBO\u201d from here on out \u2014 was established by law. (That link is to Grok\u2019s summary, and feel free to argue that there\u2019s something wrong with the summary. But be prepared to provide citations.)<br \/>[The] Congressional Budget Office (CBO) was established by the Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974 (Public Law 93-344). The Act created the CBO to provide Congress with objective, nonpartisan analysis of budgetary and economic issues, including cost estimates and deficit projections for legislation like the Big Beautiful Bill (#BBB).<br \/>There are a lot of little details to that, and we\u2019ll look at them, I promise. But one of them is this: By law \u2014 the same law \u2014the CBO must make their baseline budget projections based on the law as it stands; it may not change the baseline to suit coming changes to the law \u2014 like the ones in the BBB. <br \/>So Miller\u2019s first point is generally correct \u2014 the BBB doesn\u2019t codify most of the DOGE cuts, because by law it cannot. The DOGE cuts are almost exclusively to discretionary spending, and the distinction between mandatory and discretionary spending is established, you guessed it, by law. That same law, in fact.<br \/>What\u2019s the difference, you ask? Simply, mandatory spending is spending that is required by law under separate legislation \u2014 think Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. Discretionary spending is, well, everything else: everything that is funded by the annual budgetary process. Now, at this point, Miller slips a little bit in his discussion because he says, \u201cThe senate rules prevent it from cutting \u2018discretionary\u2019 spending.\u201d It\u2019s a tiny quibble, perhaps, but this is a discussion that is characterized on all sides by tiny quibbles made to emphasize someone\u2019s own goals and interests.<br \/>The tiny quibble is this: You can\u2019t do it in the BBB, because that\u2019s not germane to the purpose of the bill. That runs into a Senate rule called the \u201cByrd Rule,\u201d named for the former lion \u2014 or rather Exalted Cyclops \u2014 of the Senate, the late Robert C. Byrd (D-W.V.). That link will lead to a full summary of the Byrd Rule, but the important point right now is that to do anything that the Byrd Rule would forbid, you have to get 60 votes in the Senate. But what is mandatory is fixed by law. The Byrd Rule is how that law is enforced in the Senate.<br \/>Now, let\u2019s just answer the inevitable comments: \u201cWell, duh, just change the law.\u201d You\u2019re right, that is possibly desirable \u2014 but you can\u2019t change the law without getting past a filibuster. You can\u2019t do it in the BBB, because that\u2019s not germane to the purpose of the bill.<br \/>(I say \u201cpossibly desirable\u201d because it\u2019s another place where some actual thought ought to be given to whether it really is desirable. But this is already going to be too long, so I\u2019ll just refer you for the moment to the Lesson of Robespierre.)<br \/>Effect on the Deficit<br \/>So on to Miller\u2019s next point.<br \/>I\u2019ve also seen claims the bill increases the deficit. This lie is based on a CBO accounting gimmick. Income tax rates from the 2017 tax cut are set to expire in September. They were always planned to be permanent.<br \/>Calling this a lie is an overstatement. Remember that by law (there it is again), the CBO is forced to work from current law, and the current law says the 2017 tax cuts expire on December 31, 2025. So, extending the tax cuts reduces the projected tax revenue as of that date. Miller says this is an \u201caccounting gimmick,\u201d but it\u2019s an accounting gimmick that\u2019s required by law.<br \/>So, on to the next point: The BBB increases the 10-year deficit, by CBO scoring, by $3.8 trillion.<br \/>This is another one of those gaslighting exercises \u2014 because the BBB doesn\u2019t change the deficit at all, because the BBB doesn\u2019t spend money.<br \/>Appropriation bills spend money. The most the BBB can do is fiddle around with mandatory spending, which it does, and realizes about $1.6 trillion in real spending reductions by limiting who gets the money from mandatory spending. (This is kind of to a first approximation, because this bill does increase some spending by a fraction, through fiddling with mandatory spending.)<br \/>And there\u2019s the next point of confusion: The BBB does not increase the deficit. Why? Because the deficit comes from what is actually being spent, and all the CBO scoring of the BBB says is that everything else being unchanged, the deficit will increase by $3.8 trillion \u2014 over ten years, or about $380 billion per year. (It\u2019s not really a straight line, but close enough for, as they say, government work.)<br \/>At this point, it\u2019s worth remembering that, again by law, the effect of the DOGE cuts isn\u2019t taken into account in the CBO estimates. So far, the DOGE cuts already realized amount to about $175 billion \u2014 which sounds kind of trivial compared to $3.8 trillion, but remember those are permanent savings. On a ten-year basis, that\u2019s $1.75 trillion; or, going year by year, it decreases the actual deficit even without any other changes by about 46 percent.<br \/>It\u2019s only been 136 days since Trump was inaugurated. That 46 percent ain\u2019t bad.<br \/>Miller&rsquo;s Conclusion:<br \/>The bill has two fiscal components: a massive tax cut and a massive spending cut.<br \/>And that\u2019s the bottom line, and it\u2019s correct. The BBB does reduce taxes versus the CBO\u2019s expectation and current law, or, more honestly, it prevents taxes \u2014 your taxes. The \u201ctax cuts on billionaires\u201d line is errant nonsense. Actual spending in the actual next year is actually cut.<br \/>The problem here \u2014 an ongoing problem \u2014 is that a lot of the gaslighting is coming from both sides, and it\u2019s all built around ignorance or duplicity. Yes, Rand, I\u2019m looking at you. Chip Roy, you too. And include all the Senate Democrats in this as well. I\u2019ll cut Elon a little slack, because he\u2019s made himself the richest man in the world by ignoring people who tell him something can\u2019t be done. But sometimes, they\u2019re telling you something can\u2019t be done because it just can\u2019t be done.<br \/>But what the Big Beautiful Bill does do is cut spending this year by $1.6 trillion.<br \/>Now, there\u2019s a final point here. To do any of this stuff, the Big Beautiful Bill must pass! Maybe it does increase the SALT deduction for now. But that gains some important votes \u2014 and remember, the final House vote was 215-214.<br \/>Without those votes, it fails. Take your medicine \u2014 it may be bitter, but it\u2019s good for you.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Array The Big Beautiful Bill continues to be confusing, and, frankly, I think it\u2019s become confusing because a whole lot of people think it being confusing is to their advantage. So let\u2019s try to drill down into the details and try to sort out the facts.Now, Stephen Miller has tweeted an explanation a couple of [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":3216547,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"categories":[113],"tags":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/3216548"}],"collection":[{"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=3216548"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/3216548\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/3216547"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=3216548"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=3216548"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/nhub.news\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=3216548"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}