Trump’s late triumph in the fight to wrest back his brand for construction services could prove to be the first of many intellectual property victories in China during his presidency.<\/b>
SHANGHAI \u2013 President Donald Trump is poised to receive something Tuesday that he has been trying to get from China for a decade: trademark rights to his own name. After suffering rejection after rejection in China\u2019s courts, he saw his prospects change dramatically after launching his presidential campaign.
Trump\u2019s late triumph in the fight to wrest back his brand for construction services could prove to be the first of many intellectual property victories in China during his presidency. Each win creates value for Trump\u2019s business empire, and ethics questions about his administration.
READ MORE: Donald Trump still retains direct tie to business interests, documents allege
At stake are 49 pending trademark applications and 77 marks registered under his own name, most of which will come up for renewal during his term. The president could also claw back control of more than 225 Trump-related marks held or sought by others in China, for items including toilets, condoms, pacemakers and even a \u201cTrump International Hotel.\u201d
WATCH:\u00a0Justin Trudeau\u2019s high-stakes first meeting with Donald Trump
Ethics lawyers say the trademarks present conflicts of interest for Trump and may violate the emoluments clause of the U. S. Constitution, which bars public servants from accepting anything of value from foreign governments unless explicitly approved by Congress.
Countries could use Trump\u2019s desire to control his brand to extend \u2013 or withhold \u2013 favour, especially a nation such as China where the courts and bureaucracy reflect the imperatives of the ruling Communist Party.
READ MORE: 5 Donald Trump business ties that may pose conflict of interest issues
\u201cThere can be no question that it is a terrible idea for Donald Trump to be accepting the registration of these valuable property rights from China while he\u2019s a sitting president of the United States,\u201d said Norman Eisen, who served as chief White House ethics lawyer for President Barack Obama. \u201cIt\u2019s fair to conclude that this is an effort to influence Mr. Trump that is relatively inexpensive for the Chinese, potentially very valuable to him, but it could be very costly for the United States.\u201d
Eisen is involved in a lawsuit alleging that Trump\u2019s foreign business ties violate the U. S. Constitution. Trump has dismissed the lawsuit as \u201ctotally without merit.\u201d
The precise value of the trademarks is uncertain, but in a 2011 letter to then-U. S. Commerce Secretary Gary Locke, Trump wrote that he spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to defend his brand in China.
READ MORE: Donald Trump ripped by ethics czar for tapping sons to run his business
He railed against Chinese courts for not recognizing that he was famous, writing that \u201cit appears the only two places in the world I am not well known are\u201d China and Macau.
Trump\u2019s elevated profile as president will likely make it easier to protect his brand in China, said Zhou Dandan, a lawyer with Unitalen Attorneys at Law in Beijing, which has worked for Trump since 2006. Trademark authorities will almost certainly reject new \u201cTrump\u201d applications from unrelated parties, she said, and may take back rights from existing \u201cTrump\u201d trademark holders.
That\u2019s what happened in the case nearing completion this week.
Back in December 2006, Trump applied for rights to the Trump mark for construction services. He was rejected because China operates on a first-come-first-served principle and a man named Dong Wei had filed a similar application two weeks earlier. Trump appealed to Chinese authorities for 10 grinding years and was rejected time and again, right up until the month before he declared his candidacy.
Then something changed. China\u2019s trademark authorities published their decision to invalidate Dong\u2019s trademark for construction services on Sept. 6, 2016. Trump\u2019s application moved ahead, and if no one objects, the trademark will be registered to Trump on Tuesday. Dong could not be reached for comment.
Why is Trump winning now, after years of failure? China\u2019s State Administration for Industry and Commerce and its foreign ministry did not reply to requests for comment.
Alan Garten, chief legal officer of The Trump Organization, said the company \u201chas been zealously protecting its valuable brand internationally for more than 20 years.\u201d He did not answer questions about the ethical dilemmas Trump\u2019s China trademarks present for his presidency.
Some lawyers say Trump may have benefited from a general hardening in China\u2019s stance toward trademark squatters, but others believe politics played a role.
READ MORE: Donald Trump rips into \u2018fake news\u2019 report about \u2018compromising\u2019 Russian intel
\u201cIt would be hard to imagine that the judges, the Trademark Office and\/or the Trademark Review and Adjudication Board were acting without some kind of guidance,\u201d said Dan Plane, a director at Simone IP Services, a Hong Kong intellectual property consultancy.
He added that Trump may be less successful in future cases \u201cif there\u2019s a clear decision made by an angry Chinese government to stop giving broad protection to the Trump name.\u201d
Meanwhile, the makers of Trump-branded luxury toilets at Shenzhen Trump Industrial Co. face a potent new potential adversary. They say they will defend their brand, even if it means taking on the U. S. president.
Co-founder Zhong Jiye said his Trump brand, which dates to 2002, has nothing to do with President Trump. The Chinese name brings together ideas of innovation and popularity, he said. And in English, the \u201cU\u201d makes a nice toilet-seat shape logo.
Trump toilets for the home can do pregnancy tests. Models for public use have disposable seat covers for improved hygiene. People use Trump toilets some 100 million times a year, Zhong said.
Among them, he added, are customers at Zhongnanhai, the official residence of Chinese President Xi Jinping.<\/p>\n