Home United States dc3 United States mix in english pdf Why Kamala Harris Is The Real Threat To Democracy

Why Kamala Harris Is The Real Threat To Democracy

294
0
SHARE

VP Harris’s penchant for using unlawful administrative power and bypassing Congress threatens democracy and self-government.
Much wind went out of the “threat to democracy” criticism of Donald Trump when Kamala Harris replaced Joe Biden at the top of the Democrat ticket for President without a single primary vote being cast in her favor. However valid, such criticism of her coronation as a candidate misses a far more central reason why Harris poses the real threat to democracy in the presidential race. Her administration has turned loose the undemocratic Administrative State to wreak havoc on the American people in an unprecedented fashion.
The Administrative State is a catch-all name for that alphabet soup of federal agencies that exert regulatory control over people’s lives, homes, and careers. The Biden-Harris penchant for invoking administrative power, from its first hundred days of executive orders opening the border to its latest unlawful salvo aimed at winning votes from student loan debtors, seeks to legislate without involving the people’s elected representatives in Congress.The Border, Student Loan Debt, and Title IX
Numerous executive orders were used to loosen effective control of the southern border. Without Congress approving these policy changes, construction ended on the border wall, the remain-in-Mexico policy ceased, immigrants were flown around the country and deposited in unsuspecting local communities, and the CBP One app facilitated tens of thousands of appointments for still more immigrants to arrive outside normal channels. Whether or not Harris was the border czar, she owns the administration’s decision to create a porous border via executive action. This threatens democracy.
Another prominent example is the unlawful administrative cancellation of hundreds of millions in student loan debt. Money owed to the Treasury is not something the executive has plenary power to cancel (nor to transfer to taxpayers as debt), but rather than go to Congress, the Biden-Harris Administration has tried to re-interpret old statutes to have a meaning they cannot possibly contain. Even when the Supreme Court shot down that gambit, the administration cynically persisted. Trying to cancel debt faster than courts could stop them, or faster than litigants with standing could be found to oppose them, the administration has tried to force a policy outcome that has never—and could never—amass majority support in Congress. This threatens democracy.
A third area where Harris & Co. have ignored Congress is in forcing school districts to interpret Title IX in a novel way that would require allowing biological men into women’s locker rooms and other private spaces and onto women’s sports teams. Whatever one’s personal views, such a momentous and divisive policy change demands democratic input. Yet this administration’s no-compromise policies have repeatedly used administrative power without even trying to get majority support in Congress. This threatens democracy.Pandemic Policies
From the outset, the Biden-Harris administration used multiple executive actions to restrict Americans’ freedom during the pandemic. First, it extended the nationwide eviction moratorium for over a year and a half without approval from Congress. Even when the Supreme Court rejected the idea that CDC quarantine power extended to foreclosing evictions (and shutting down landlord-tenant courts), Biden-Harris renewed its efforts saying that it could buy a few more months before the courts could react. This behavior earned an instant rebuke from the Supreme Court. It also threatens democracy.
Most unconscionably, Biden-Harris mandated experimental vaccinations for soldiers, federal employees, federal contractors, healthcare workers in facilities receiving federal funding, and it tried to even do so for all workplaces regulated by OSHA through an exotic (and ultimately Supreme Court-rejected) interpretation of the Occupational Safety and Health Act. Opinions may differ on who should have gotten voluntarily vaccinated, but this administration’s efforts to maximally force mRNA injections into the arms of every possible citizen never sought or received congressional input. This threatens democracy.Censorship and Courtpacking
Harris has shown anti-democratic tendencies when it comes to the First Amendment as well. This administration hatched a widespread, multi-agency effort to censor opposition voices across all the main social media platforms. Discovery from the Missouri v. Biden lawsuit and the Twitter files’ release exposed the administration’s deep disregard for First Amendment freedoms. Citing the desire to combat supposed “disinformation, misinformation, and malinformation,” Harris (joined by Tim Walz on the campaign trail), has defended those efforts to take down even truthful information. The government has no right to remove lawful speech—nor to ask the platforms to take it down. This drastic curtailing of free speech, which Congress itself could not authorize, threatens democracy.
President Biden eschewed packing the U.S. Supreme Court, but candidate Harris has not foresworn that destabilizing idea. Instead, she and her running mate have doubled down on Court criticism. Progressives express concern over the loss of Chevron deference to the legal interpretations of administrative agencies. This summer’s decision in Loper Bright/Relentless will make it harder to govern without congressional input going forward. So too, Harris has been part of unleashing agencies like the Securities and Exchange Commission to adopt “whole-of-government” approaches to topics ranging from climate change to DEI. These Congress-free initiatives have produced travesties like the Consolidated Audit Trail—a national database containing full information about the stock transactions of every American. This too threatens democracy.Lawfare Antics and Preserving Self-Government
Finally, consider the anti-democratic maneuvers Harris & Co. employed to prevent former President Trump (and Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., for that matter, who was denied Secret Service protection among other slights) from running for re-election to the presidency via lawfare. By appointing a special counsel from outside government, timing prosecutions to interfere with campaign time, forcing an unprecedented search of Mar-a-Lago, prosecuting for official acts and more, Biden-Harris have politicized the Department of Justice to get Trump by any means necessary. And it’s not just Trump. The multi-pronged agency attack on Elon Musk’s companies in the wake of his Twitter purchase is a frightening form of lawfare, too. Even billionaires cannot withstand a concerted assault by a federal government with limitless resources and a grudge.
These examples illustrate how Kamala Harris threatens democracy by empowering bureaucracies at the expense of representative government. Preventing bureaucrats from making laws is essential to preserving self-government. So, voters who truly wish to save democracy on November 5 should consider the Administrative State’s aggressive role in restricting their freedom under the Biden-Harris Administration before assuming that a future President Harris is the safer bet. If Harris prevails on Tuesday, do not be surprised if the Administrative State restricts more and more freedom with less and less input from the people’s representatives in Congress over the next four years. If instead Trump wins on Tuesday, expect Congress to have a far greater role—and the Administrative State a much lesser role—in writing the laws that govern Americans’ lives and livelihoods. Anyone who claims to care about saving democracy should vote accordingly.